Forum

Please Remove the Guild Insignia Bonus I think giving that to player was a big mistake, and you guy should remove these bonuses. The only reason i see to why this mechanism has been created was to make guild leveling more wanted, but it gives SO MUCH MORE damage to the game than benefits that i don't see how it can be sustained. Here a list of reasons to why remove the system:

- Reduce the number of guilds & Add unwanted players to the bigger ones: A lot of people don't want to create a guild from scratch because of the hard work they would have to get this bonus, so instead the enter with their friends in a major one, keep leeching them, do not interact with the community there (just stay with their circle of friends) and, that guild not being the top level anymore, leave it to go to a bigger one.

- Create tension within the guild: A lot of guilds want to be on top, to get more members and reputation, and for that they ask to the members to donate XP. People don't need this reward to try evolve their guild, and when you put these bonus things just get worse, making this "race" much more intense, creating "goals" to achieve and anger between the members that give xp and the ones that only use this bonus without giving XP back to the guild, for whatever reason they have.

- Ruin the fashion value of other insignias: As Shiraf said some times in his "Lets Talk Wakfu", very few people will use an aesthetics insignia when they have one that gives bonus. This not only ruin your guys Shop system as it removes one great fun of the game, the customization of our char's appearance.

- It isn't necessary to make the Guild Leveling and Guild Insignia wanted: We don't need its bonus to want to level our guild, every one wants his guild to appear better than the others, as we want to be able to use our guild's uniform completely, especially when we are in GvG or other situations like that. The Guild Ranking and the Insignia equipment unlocks do the job just fine, the in-game bonus are not needed.

- Guilds are losing their motive to exist: Why would you enter a guild? to talk with people, have fun, ask help, use a banner that means something to you and that you want to defend it.
Now people are entering in guilds they don't know nothing about, using a symbol they don't like, some times not even opening the chat tab because they don't make contact with the community, even because when they open it there is always someone telling them to give XP to level the guild. Even the low level players that keep only asking us to help leveling them make contact with other players, interact and a good number of times stay in the guild after leveling up, not this "pit-stop leveling party" that it became. Please remove this system, this is not why guilds are supposed to exist.

Could you imagine the uproar if they did remove it?

You can't just add a bonus to the game that a lot of people like then remove it, there would be chaos.

i agree with this post completely, Guilds were meant to be just communities and entirely community based, they turned it into a competition and involved stats...

the guild bonus should be much more balanced, like you can only select one of the bonuses, that would make it better (and the bonuses should not be better or worse than eachother, just different)

i remember when people made guilds just for talking to other players and making friends, i really miss that

Lol the guild bonuses are so weak personally I think they should be double or increased even more level 20 +10% damage ....that is so weak when you do 1,000 a turn the extra 10% would at 20 damage for all the TIME. I dont think that 20 extra damage is going to change the winner of the fight do you?

• +5 wisdom
• +5 pp
• +30 hp
• +5% resistance
• +10% damage

Everything is up to the players and the guild themselves the bonuses are just that extras I personally think its simply a reward to all the level 105 so they exp is not 100% wasted when they actually play the game.

I like the competitiveness of the guild ranking system, I admit levelling craft exp is not that much fun.
There are 1773 guilds on the game so your other comment seem to be untrue.

If you guild leader gives you tension tell him where to go!, its a game, I ask my member to be on 1% until level 105 and 0% craft exp if we want to level the guild we do it together and have a little contest between us or at the very least farm close to each other.

Ruin the fashion value of other insignias -I agree.

Guilds are losing their motive to exist=rubbish every guild is unique and there are 1773 of them, it is true people will join the top 10 just for the guild bonus and not contribute at all but that happened before there was guild levels no this problem has increase by if the officer and guild leaders are active they can talk to the member.


This post has been edited by JerryDB - July 24, 2012, 11:19:01.